Classic Potato Salad Recipe (2024)

Reading the last line of the intro, I think it is funny that my kids (all older adults now) to this day think I make the best "Mom's mashed potato salad" ever. When they were young I was always in a hurry and often made potato salad with very warm potatoes. As it was mixed the potatoes broke up and some were very like mashed potatoes and others helter-skelter chunks. They and others love it to this day. I have made it with cooled potatoes and they don't absorb the flavors that warm ones do.

I’m a Southern girl, potato salad without chopped hard boiled eggs is unthinkable. You’re welcome.

'Brining' your cooked potatoes in pickle juice or relish juice adds a ton of flavor to this dish!

I love the comments on this recipe. The variations and your way of sharing them makes me feel I’m getting to know you all at a picnic! Here in Nova Scotia we eat potato salad - hard boiled eggs included - with lobster and sliced tomatoes on the side.

Don't bother with the granulated onion use regular onions finely diced, and add a little of the relish juice over warm potatoes . I use the hard boiled eggs in two ways, mash the yolks into the dressing and dice the whites and add to the potatoes. To get the best taste add the dressing when the potatoes are still a little warm, mix gently and refrigerate. Any variation is good with this salad a little horseradish adds a nice zip to it also.

The russets were cooked, peeled and cubed early in the morning. While hot added the cider vinegar. Put in frig until afternoon and then finished the rest.. My mom always added a small jar of chopped Dromedary diced pimentos and fine chopped baby jerkin's instead of relish. Still use the same large yellow Pyrex bowl

Try using 1/2 cup sour cream and 1/2 cup mayonnaise. (Duke's mayo, of course!)Fresh dill, finely diced, is great in potato salad.I use red potatoes and leave the skin on.

My mom added some celery seed. Anyone got a problem with that?

I would finely chopped the celery and add 1/3 cup of finely chopped yellow onions to this recipe.

I have to say I love the hard boiled eggs in the salad!

This is very nearly the potato salad my mother taught me to make when I was a little girl. We boiled russet potatoes whole, then peeled and cut them into cubes while still hot/warm. A little hard on the fingers, but boiling cubed russets, it seems to me, would cause them to get soggy. We always had a certain proportion of mashed to cubed potatoes, as the outsides were more cooked than the insides, but that was part of the goodness of the dish.

This is what I grew up with and made my recipe-free version last week. Use green/yellow/white onions but never dried/powdered. Also, boil your eggs with your potatoes. A bit of horseradish gives it a nice zing too.

This is a great basic recipe but I stand with those who use diced sweet onions versus powder. I’ll add other ingredients depending on what’s at hand. Peas or seedless cucumber, leftover ham or bacon, whatever yellow mustard enhances.

When you cut up the potatoes use all parts not just the cubes, no one really checks to make sure that every piece is cubed

Re HB eggs in potato salad: the yolks crumble into the dressing, changing the consistency slightly - and they do add nutrition, of course.

I always bake my potatoes for potato salad. Bake them the day before and put them in the refrigerator overnight. Chopped HB eggs, finely minced onion and dill pickles. Mayo, yellow mustard,salt,pepper and pickle juice whisked together for the dressing. I get lots of compliments on my potato salad.

"Separately, fry up a few strips of bacon. Save the grease in the pan, let it cool down. Slice-or-crumble the bacon and stir into the potato salad. Dump the bacon fat into the potato salad. Stir. Write the phone number for your cardiologist and put it next to the telephone."

Mom was raised in southern Idaho, used russets where they are grown. She used russets because the soil had volcanic ash that gave russets more flavor than other types of potatoes. Mom would use some onion powder, but also finely diced green onions including the scallion that added some color. The rest of the recipe is the same, and it is the best. My friends ask for it.

To add some flavor, mix in a simple French vinaigrette (olive oil, vinegar, salt, paprika) to the warm potatoes, then chill them several hours or overnight before adding the remaining ingredients. (IIRC, this tip is from my mom’s 1947 Women’s Home Companion Cookbook).

Well I have 3 pounds of undercooked potatoes potato salad. The author wrote twice not to overcook the potatoes and I overthought the instruction.

I thought these were pretty dry and needed a lot more seasoning. And I would say it makes 8 servings for people who want a whole lot of potato salad. I used slightly under 3 lbs of Yukon Gold potatoes and 5 hard boiled eggs for a BBQ for 7 and we probably eat about a quarter of the amount this recipe made.

Used this recipe as my base but made several changes: small sweet onion diced instead of powder and pickles diced instead of sweet relish… I also only used 4 eggs, which was enough for me personally. If anyone is looking for additional guidance on the potato cookery, I suggest Serious Eats’ potato salad recipe. I cooked the potatoes according to their directions, adding 2 tbsp salt and apple cider vinegar to the water. Cook for 10 min once boiling with potatoes starting in the cool water.

I add sliced olives to mine. And add the olive juice to the potato water when boiling them and adjust the added salt.

My favorite potato salad recipe; just the basics. I would caution not to add additional salt as the relish and mayo are already salty.

1 cup mayo = 226 grams1/4 relish = 70 grams

Thought this came out fantastic. I took note of what others had suggested and I poured some pickle juice over the warm potatoes. So good. I also finely chopped a few dill baby gherkins to add in the dressing with the sweet relish.

Didn't have dill or celery, used some pickled beets from a store bought glass jar. Maybe a third of a beet and a tablespoon of the juice. Added a nice color, but obviously no crunch, also added about half a teaspoon of wasabi paste. It turned out tasty.

Sweet pickle relish in potato salad is just plain wrong...hotdogs only. Never in any of the "salads": potato, tuna, chicken, ham, egg...never; just on hotdogs (if even that).Chopped onions and chopped celery are a must...no onion powder. Hellman's or Duke's mayo...no others especially Kraft salad dressing.

Midwest African American here. My mother would never leave out small bits of sweet pickle and carefully diced bits of fresh tomato, never peeled. The pickles' sweetness blended intoxicatingly with the eggs and potato. The skin still on the diced tomato added a savor and texture to the eating. (Mustard would have canceled all of this.) Eating this with crisp fried chicken, drinking cherry Kool-Aid, followed by cold watermelon, we knew we were in deep summer.

Double the number of hard boiled eggs and add one for a garnish. Celery is a must. Use two finely chopped stalks of green onions and forget the powder. Best Foods/ Hellman's for the Mayo and add 2/3 of a cup of chopped sweet pickles- the Heintz 57 brand is by far the best.