Why Won't My Yorkshire Puddings Rise? The Secrets to Perfect Yorkshire Puddings | Lockhart Catering Blog (2024)

Lightly crispy and fluffy on the outside, soft and chewy in the middle and gorgeously golden-brown in colour, a perfect Yorkshire pudding is almost a work of art – but as even the most accomplished chefs will know, they’re really not easy to master.

We’ve all experienced the disappointment of limp, flat, burnt or even runny Yorkshire puddings, but don’t be disheartened; with a little troubleshooting, you too can be a Yorkshire pudding pro!

A post shared by Jamie Oliver (@jamieoliver) on

The annual Yorkshire Day takes place each year on 1st August, but with our Yorkshire pudding secrets (and science) below, you can enjoy pudding perfection at any time of year. Do you have any tips for flawless Yorkshire puddings more to add to our list? Leave us a comment below, or send us a tweet @BunzlLockhart – if you don’t mind sharing!

Adding water to the batter will make your puddings lighter and crispier

Yorkshire puddings are made up of the basic ingredients of flour, eggs, and milk, but some recipes call for water to be added to the batter too. The general rule of thumb is that substituting some, or even half of the milk in your recipe for water will make your puddings lighter and crispier, so try this modification if your puds are too dense or soft.

The amount of eggs that you use matters, too – use an equal amount of flour, eggs and milk or water. For six servings of Yorkshire puddings, you should use four large eggs.

The batter must have the consistency of single cream

Start with the flour and eggs, and then add your milk (and water if you wish) gradually until you achieve the desired consistency. Then leave the batter at room temperature for around 15 minutes – enough time for you to heat the pudding tin and fat in the oven, ready for baking.

All lumps must be completely removed from the batter

A lumpy Yorkshire pudding batter could never a perfect pudding make, so use a large balloon whisk to beat the batter thoroughly and get plenty of air into the mixture. If you really want to remove every tiny lump, pour it through a fine metal strainer, then give it one last whisk.

The fat must be smoking hot in the pan before you cook the batter

If your Yorkshire pudding tin isn’t hot enough before the batter is added, all attempts are destined to flop – so add fat or oil to the tin, and heat in the top of the oven at 230?C for 10 minutes first (and keep it at that temperature when cooking). It must be smoking hot before you pour in the pudding mixture, and the batter should sizzle when you drop an oil into the fat. Keep the tin hot on the hob as you add the mixture.

Speaking of the fat, traditionally Yorkshire puddings are made with beef fat or lard, but a vegetarian and vegan-friendly option is to use vegetable oil (never olive oil or butter), which can be heated to the required high temperature without burning.

The Yorkshire pudding tins must not be over-filled

Over-filling your Yorkshire pudding tin will lead to heavy puddings, which won’t rise to lofty heights. Whether you’re making individual Yorkshire puddings or a large pud to carve up, only fill the tin about a third of the way for optimum puds.

Never open the oven door during cooking

For Yorkshire puddings to soar, the temperature must too – so never open the oven door when they are cooking, to keep the oven as hot as possible. If opening the oven door is absolutely essential your Yorkshire puddings won’t be ruined, but they just won’t rise as much as they should.

For everything you need to whip up picture-perfect Yorkshire puddings, take a look at our range of Catering Appliances to find the ideal oven for your restaurant kitchen, plus our huge Kitchen Equipment collection for whisks, mixing bowls, Yorkshire pudding tins and much more.

Do you have any Yorkshire pudding tips of your own to add to our list? Or have you found any of ours helpful? Let us know by sending us a tweet @BunzlLockhart!

Why Won't My Yorkshire Puddings Rise? The Secrets to Perfect Yorkshire Puddings | Lockhart Catering Blog (2024)

FAQs

Why Won't My Yorkshire Puddings Rise? The Secrets to Perfect Yorkshire Puddings | Lockhart Catering Blog? ›

The fat must be smoking hot in the pan before you cook the batter. If your Yorkshire pudding tin isn't hot enough before the batter is added, all attempts are destined to flop – so add fat or oil to the tin, and heat in the top of the oven at 230? C for 10 minutes first (and keep it at that temperature when cooking).

Why has my Yorkshire pudding not rising? ›

The fat isn't hot enough (it should be smoking hot). The oven isn't getting hot enough (needs to maintain a 220C/425F temperature). Your oven loses heat too quickly when you open the oven door and/or you leave the oven door open for too long whilst you're filling up the Yorkshire pudding tins with batter.

What is the secret to making Yorkshire pudding rise? ›

Make sure the tin with the fat in is really hot before you pour the batter in. And don't open the oven door again till the end! letting it rest at room temperature helps it rise taller as it bakes. A combination of milk and water gives the Yorkshire puddings extra rise and crispness.

How to stop Yorkshire pudding from deflating? ›

Bake Yorkshire puddings on the top shelf of your oven as this is where it's hottest. Get the oil as hot as you can! It should sizzle when you add the batter. Don't open the oven door during cooking or they could deflate.

What is the raising agent in Yorkshire puddings? ›

Steam is a common physical raising agent. It is produced from the liquids (e.g. water, milk, eggs) that are added to mixtures, or from water contained in a solid component (e.g. butter). Examples of recipes which use steam as a raising agent are batters (e.g. Yorkshire pudding) and choux pastry.

Why didn't my batter rise? ›

Measure Your Ingredients

If you use too much flour, the resulting pudding will be heavy and dense. Without enough egg, there will be insufficient air beaten in for a successful rise. Too much milk will make the batter too loose.

Should Yorkshire pudding batter be thick or runny? ›

Yes, the batter should be runny, about the consistency of heavy cream. Here is my very quick, easy and amazing cheap recipe together with some important points which will make sure the puddings are a success.

Should you stir Yorkshire pudding batter after resting? ›

Let your batter rest

Our no-fail yorkies recipe recommends transferring your batter to a jug after mixing, then leaving it to rest for at least 15 minutes. If you leave your batter to rest overnight, as is the case in our mushroom yorkshires recipe, make sure you give it a good stir before cooking.

Can you put too much oil in Yorkshire pudding? ›

Too much will make the bottom of your Yorkshires greasy, while too little could see your puds stick to the pan.

Should you add baking powder to Yorkshire pudding? ›

Plain flour is key, according to the Brits. The addition of bicarb or baking powder should not be added to the mix at all, and can even cause the puds to become flat, dense, or even burn.

Does an extra egg help Yorkshire puddings rise? ›

If you want to go Instagram-ready with sky-high fluffy Yorkshires, add an extra egg white to your batter. They'll tower over the competition. With that in mind, always make sure your Yorkshire puddings have room to rise in the oven.

Why do my Yorkshire puddings sink when I take them out? ›

If it's as soon as you take it out, it's a problem with it being undercooked. If it takes a few minutes to deflate, it can be an issue with cooling them too quickly. You can get around this problem by taking a sharp knife or skewer and poking a couple of holes in the top of each one.

How high should a Yorkshire pudding be? ›

The Yorkshire pudding is meant to rise. The Royal Society of Chemistry suggested in 2008 that "A Yorkshire pudding isn't a Yorkshire pudding if it is less than four inches [10 cm] tall". In a 2012 poll conducted by T-Mobile UK, the Yorkshire pudding was ranked tenth in a list of things people love about Britain.

Why is my Yorkshire pudding not rising? ›

The fat must be smoking hot in the pan before you cook the batter. If your Yorkshire pudding tin isn't hot enough before the batter is added, all attempts are destined to flop – so add fat or oil to the tin, and heat in the top of the oven at 230? C for 10 minutes first (and keep it at that temperature when cooking).

What is the key to making Yorkshire puddings rise? ›

Resting the batter overnight is key for developing better flavor. Forget about cold batter: letting it rest at room temperature helps it rise taller as it bakes. A combination of milk and water gives the Yorkshire puddings extra rise and crispness.

Is it better to use butter or oil for Yorkshire puddings? ›

What is best oil or fat for Yorkshire puddings? Gordon Ramsay's recipe calls for vegetable oil or beef dripping, but you can also use sunflower oil, lard or solid vegetable shortening. Avoid olive oil or butter as they burn easily and have low 'smoke' points.

Why do my Yorkshire puddings go flat when they come out of the oven? ›

The most likely cause is that the fat in your tins isn't hot enough when you pour in the batter. I use beef dripping in my tins. Make sure to put a decent amount in each tin, don't just smear the tins with it. Your oven needs to be very hot 230°c.

Why are my Yorkshire puddings doughy in the middle? ›

If the batter in the centre still remains under cooked then you may need to reduce the oven temperature by 20-40c (50-75F) after the initial cooking and give the pudding an extra 5 minutes in the lower oven at the end to cook through.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated:

Views: 6000

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.